Table of Contents
Italy is a paradise for rail travelers. Why? Because it is one of the few countries in Europe with two competing high-speed rail companies.
On one side, you have Trenitalia (the state-owned giant). On the other, Italo (the private, modern challenger).
They compete fiercely for passengers on routes like Rome-Milan or Venice-Florence. This competition means lower prices and better service for you.
But as a tourist, which one should you choose? Is Italo too good to be true? Is Trenitalia old-fashioned?
Here is the ultimate showdown to help you decide.
The Contenders
1. Trenitalia (Frecciarossa)
This is the national railway of Italy. Their flagship high-speed trains are called Frecciarossa (“Red Arrow”).
- The Vibe: Established, professional, massive network.
- Reach: Goes everywhere. From big cities to tiny coastal villages (using connecting regional trains).
2. Italo (NTV)
Launched in 2012, Italo is the private competitor. It was co-founded by the former boss of Ferrari, and the trains definitely have a “Ferrari” vibe—sleek, modern, and dark red.
- The Vibe: Modern, stylish, budget-friendly.
- Reach: Limited. They only serve the main high-speed lines connecting major cities (Turin, Milan, Venice, Florence, Rome, Naples).
Round 1: Comfort & Seats
Italo takes the win for “Standard Class” luxury. Even in their cheapest class (called Smart), the seats are leather (by Poltrona Frau) and very comfortable. They also have a Cinema Coach on some trains showing movies.
Trenitalia is excellent, but their Standard class usually has cloth seats. However, if you are willing to splurge, Trenitalia’s Executive Class is unbeatable—it has only 8-10 massive swivel chairs in the whole carriage and includes a full meal and free-flowing prosecco.
Winner: Italo for budget travelers (leather seats for cheap). Trenitalia for luxury travelers (Executive Class).
Round 2: Network & Frequency
This is where Trenitalia flexes its muscles. Because it is the state railway, it runs far more trains per day. If you miss your 10:00 AM Trenitalia train, there is another one at 10:15 AM. Italo might not have another one until 10:40 AM.
Also, Italo only stops at major stations.
- If you are going Rome to Venice? Both are great.
- If you are going Rome to Cinque Terre or Lake Como? You need Trenitalia, because Italo doesn’t go to the smaller regional stops.
Winner: Trenitalia (More trains, more destinations).
Round 3: Price
Italo positions itself as the budget-friendly option. If you book 2-3 months in advance, you can often snag Italo tickets for as low as €9.90 or €19.90 between Rome and Florence.
Trenitalia has sales too (look for “Super Economy” fares), but on average, Italo tends to be slightly cheaper, especially for last-minute bookings.
Winner: Italo (Usually lighter on the wallet).
The Verdict: Which One Should You Book?
Honestly? The difference in quality is minimal. Both travel at 300km/h (186 mph), both have free Wi-Fi, and both are faster than flying.
Choose Italo if:
- You are traveling between major hubs (e.g., Rome-Milan, Venice-Florence).
- You want to save €5-€10 per ticket.
- You like leather seats.
Choose Trenitalia if:
- You need a specific departure time (more options).
- You are connecting to a smaller town (like Sorrento, Pisa, or Cinque Terre).
- You want to experience the ultra-luxury of Executive Class.
How to Compare Prices Instantly?
Don’t waste time opening two different websites and switching tabs. Use a comparison tool to see both Trenitalia and Italo trains on the same list, side-by-side.
